The minivan segment has been in decline as of late, with many families electing to switch over to crossovers and SUVs rather than stick with the "mommy van." Automakers have obviously noticed the lagging sales, but have just recently began to do something about it.

When all is said and done, 2011 may just be remembered as the "year of the minivan," as all the major models got redesigns for the year. With at least six brand-new cars for sale to choose from, it can be understandably tricky for a family to pick the one that's right for them.

That's why Cars.com partnered up with MotorWeek and USA Today for the first ever "Ultimate Minivan Shootout," a rigorous three days of testing that would decide which model rose to the top. A selection of auto experts from the three publications as well as a family of five all tested the Dodge Grand Caravan, Honda Odyssey, Chrysler Town and Country, Toyota Sienna, Nissan Quest and Volkswagen Routan over the three days. Each were given a comprehensive scorecard, with all the pros and cons converted to numerical figures
and tallied up. All minivans were similarly equipped and retailed for less than $45,000.

While they eventually came up with a clear winner, no model was deemed completely worthless. The reviewers didn't like the Toyota Sienna, as it came in last place, but they praised its smooth ride, excellent performance and available all-wheel drive. The Dodge Grand Caravan, in fifth overall, was deemed an excellent value – its $34,000 price tag made it much cheaper than the other cars on the list.

The Routan was similarly priced as the Grand Caravan, but held a number of advantages – like a rear-seat DVD and second-row seating. That was enough to earn it fourth place overall. And in third place, the Nissan Quest was deemed the best of the bunch by two of its reviewers – but its lack of standard features and odd styling ultimately held it back.

Things got close at the top of the list, but the Honda Odyssey ultimately beat out the Chrysler Town and Country to win the shootout. Both vehicles were praised, with reviewers and family alike praising Chrysler's luxurious interior and the Odyssey's extensive features.

Of course, drivers should keep in mind that these are only the results of one test. Earlier this year, Edmunds Inside Line ran a very similar test with some wildly different results. With performance more of a factor, the Sienna actually ended up as the best overall, with the Quest and Odyssey tying for second. The two American models brought up the rear, and the Routan wasn't even tested.

If you're looking to buy a used minivan, you might want to head down to New Jersey State Auto Auction. They have nearly every model available, and you can take your time and do your own minivan shootout to see which you like the best.